4am Test Series Day35
Examine the reasons for the criminalization of politics in India. Discuss the impact of this phenomenon on the functioning of democracy. Suggest measures to curb the spread of criminalization in politics.
UPSC Mains Syllabus topic
Appointment to various Constitutional posts, powers, functions andresponsibilities of various Constitutional Bodies. Statutory,regulatory and various quasi-judicial bodies.
Why was this question asked?
(Theme- Criminalisation of Politics)
- Simultaneous election to the Lok Sabha and the State Assemblies will limit the amount of time and money spent in electioneering but it will reduce the government’s accountability to the people (2017)
Introduction: The criminalization of politics in India has become a grave concern, with a significant number of legislators having criminal backgrounds or pending cases against them. (Data Point [According to Association for Democratic Reforms]- The share of MPs with criminal and serious criminal cases increased to 43% and 29%, according to an analysis of 539 winners in the 2019 Lok Sabha elections.)
Body
Reasons for Criminalization of Politics:
I. Manipulative Vote Bank Politics:
- The susceptibility of a significant number of voters to manipulation and influence allows candidates with dubious backgrounds to be elected.
- Exploitation of organized vote bank politics further perpetuates the support for candidates associated with criminal activities.
II. Rampant Corruption:
- The escalating number of legislators with criminal records reflects the deep-rooted connection between crime and politics.
- Corruption practices such as bribery and illicit funding contribute to the perpetuation of criminalization in politics.
III. Weaknesses in Election Commission Functioning:
- Inadequate enforcement of the Model Code of Conduct allows candidates to openly flout regulations without facing stringent consequences.
- Insufficient measures to combat electoral malpractices facilitate the entry of criminals into the political arena.
IV. Impediments to Justice and Rule of Law:
- Ineffectiveness of laws pertaining to convicted criminals contesting elections undermines the credibility of the justice system.
- The backlog of pending cases and delayed judgments provide opportunities for criminals to sustain their involvement in politics.
Impact of Criminalization of Politics:
I. Erosion of Public Trust in the Judiciary:
- The presence of politicians with criminal backgrounds undermines public confidence in the impartiality and effectiveness of the judiciary.
- Politicized law enforcement agencies hamper the delivery of justice, resulting in a decline in trust among citizens.
II. Violation of Democratic Values:
- Criminal activities during the electoral process impede the conduct of free and fair elections, which are the bedrock of a healthy democracy.
- The presence of lawmakers with criminal records contradicts the fundamental principles of democracy.
III. Deterioration of Electoral Culture:
- The perpetuation of criminalization in politics leads to a decline in ethical standards within the political sphere.
- If criminals gain prominence in the political arena, the overall electoral culture suffers, undermining the legitimacy of the democratic process.
Measures to Curb Criminalization of Politics:
I. Early Disqualification:
- Implementing the recommendation of the Law Commission to disqualify tainted politicians at the stage of framing charges can act as a deterrent to the entry of criminals into politics.
- Adequate safeguards must be established to protect innocent candidates from false charges.
II. Stringent Penalties for False Affidavits:
- Recognizing the filing of a false affidavit as a corrupt practice under the Representation of the People Act can discourage dishonesty.
- Conviction for filing a false affidavit should lead to disqualification, ensuring accountability and integrity in the political sphere.
III. Disrupting the Nexus:
- The Election Commission must proactively undertake measures to sever the deep-rooted ties between criminals and politicians.
- Rigorous enforcement and regular monitoring can help break this detrimental nexus, safeguarding the integrity of the political process.
Conclusion: By addressing the underlying reasons, adopting comprehensive reforms, and ensuring the implementation of stricter measures, India can foster a political landscape characterized by integrity, transparency, and the true representation of its citizens’ interests.
For more content
